Your Cart

The Newcomer by Mary Kay Andrew is a Delightful Blend of Mystery and Romance

Spoiler in case you don't feel like reading the full review: 5/5 stars! ★★★★★


The Newcomer by Mary Kay Andrews is a captivating tale that masterfully combines elements of mystery, romance, and the charm of a coastal town. This novel is a delightful escape that promises to keep readers engaged from start to finish.


The story revolves around Letty Carnahan, who, after discovering her sister Tanya's body, becomes the prime suspect in her murder. Driven by Tanya's final warning, Letty flees with her four-year-old niece, Maya, to a beachside motel in Florida, a place Tanya once hinted was crucial to her safety. This marks the beginning of a thrilling journey filled with secrets, suspense, and unexpected allies.


Mary Kay Andrews' writing is, as always, enchanting. Her ability to paint vivid pictures of the coastal setting immerses readers in the atmosphere of the run-down Murmuring Surf motel, making it almost a character in itself. The detailed descriptions of the beach, the charming yet quirky residents, and the bustling life of Treasure Island provide a perfect backdrop for the unfolding drama.


Letty is a wonderfully relatable protagonist and her relationship with her niece is super endearing. I love their cute food nicknames for each other! Letty's fierce determination to protect Maya, coupled with her vulnerability and the grief of losing her sister, makes her a character readers can root for. The relationship she develops with Joe, the local police detective, adds a delightful layer of romance to the narrative. Their chemistry is palpable, and their growing trust in each other amidst the swirling suspicions is beautifully portrayed.


The mystery element of the story is expertly crafted. Andrews keeps readers on their toes with a well-paced plot and cleverly placed clues. The revelations are satisfying, and the resolution is both surprising and plausible, tying up loose ends in a manner that feels both complete and rewarding.


In The Newcomer, Mary Kay Andrews also touches on themes of family, resilience, and starting over. The community at the Murmuring Surf, with its eclectic mix of residents, provides a heartwarming example of finding support and friendship in unexpected places. The secondary characters are well-developed, each adding their own unique flavor to the story.


This book is a must-read for anyone looking for a well-crafted mystery with a touch of romance and a whole lot of heart.


Book Review of The Newcomer by Mary Kay Andrews